Water Softener vs Whole House Filtration | Clear Water Concepts (2024)

Water Softener vs Whole House Filtration | Clear Water Concepts (1)

Water that comes to the tap also comes with contaminants. A study from the Environmental Working Group found carcinogenic chromium-6, which comes from waste products from agriculture and manufacturing industries, present in drinking water nearly 200 million Americans drink in all 50 states. American tap water can also contain impurities like mercury, lead and arsenic.

Even bottled water isn’t that much better. The EWG found 38 contaminants in 10 popular bottled water brands.

Besides the negative effects contaminated water has on taste, scent and health, minerals in water can clog up your pipes and drive up your water bill. Magnesium and calcium buildup in water creates hard water, which leaves behind a gross filmy residue on otherwise clean dishes, plus your hair and skin.

So what’s the best way to remove minerals and contaminants in water? The EWG recommends using a whole-house water filter for the safest water intake. But does a whole-house filtration system also fix hard water? Does a water softener purify water? Here are the differences you should consider when choosing a water processing system.

What’s Water Softening?

Water should clean things, not leave them grimy. Hard water is water that contains minerals like calcium or magnesium in it. When it’s used in the shower, it can leave your hair feeling filmy. It’s difficult to create a lather when washing your hands or hair. After washing dishes in the dishwasher, your glasses may look foggy from the minerals left behind. And hard water creates build-up in pipes that make water usage less efficient — using more water and causing water bills to skyrocket.

Water softening is the process of removing those minerals from hard water so that those problems also disappear. A water softener has polystyrene beads with sodium chloride ions. When the hard water passes over those beads, the mineral ions exchange with the sodium chloride ions. The amount of sodium is minuscule, so if you drink soft water or use it in cooking, it doesn’t have a salty taste.

Do I Need a Water Softener?

Hard water levels depend on the water sources the water is coming from. In the Phoenix area, the United States Geological Survey reports hard water levels are among the highest in the country. If you live in Arizona and don’t use a water softener, you’re likely to encounter the effects of hard water.

Water Softener Cost

The average cost of a water softener installation ranges between $800 to $3,000, depending on the type of water softener unit and the size of the home. Considering how much money you lose because of inefficient hard water delivery, a water softener is a cost-effective investment that protects your water quality.

What Is Whole-House Filtration?

Remember those yucky contaminants? A whole-house filtration system removes pollutants and contaminants from water. If you have a water softener but no filtration system, you’ll have removed the minerals from your water, but you still may be drinking, cooking and bathing in contaminants and chemicals like:

  • Bacteria
  • Heavy metals
  • Chlorine by-products

A whole-house filtration system treats the water at its point of entry into a household. That means, no matter what tap, showerhead or other water source you’re using, the water has been treated.

Some water treatment systems only treat water at a sink or in a refrigerator for ice. But we use water in so many other ways than in the kitchen: to brush our teeth, to wash our hands and clothes, to shower with, to fill up a kiddie pool outside with, etc. All water that comes from your home can be treated with whole-house filtration.

How Whole-House Filtration Works

Water Softener vs Whole House Filtration | Clear Water Concepts (2)

  1. Water entering your home enters a pre-filter, which removes larger impurities and contaminants from water, like sediment.
  2. The water is filtered for chlorine and volatile organic chemicals, which can also affect your home’s air quality after they evaporate.
  3. Water then goes through activated carbon, which removes contaminants like pesticides, copper and herbicides.
  4. The water then enters a polishing filtration phase, which removes any remaining sediment and organic particles.

Whole-House Filtration Cost

Whole-house water filtration systems remove contaminants that can affect your family’s health. You can get a whole-house filtration system for around anywhere from $1,000 to $2,300. Installation costs range from $200 to $900.

Combine Whole-House Filtration and Water Softening

Water Softener vs Whole House Filtration | Clear Water Concepts (3)

For the best quality water, a combination of water softening and whole-house filtration is the ideal solution. The minerals from hard water can decrease the effectiveness of whole-house filtration and decrease the quality of the water — and your lifestyle and pipes.

Using a water softener with whole-house filtration produces the cleanest, purest water. Check out the Evolv Whole-House Water Filtration and Softener System to learn more.

If you want to protect your health and the taste, scent and integrity of your water, contact the Clear Water Concepts team. We’ll help you learn options for selecting a water softener and/or whole-house filtration system for your home.

Water Softener vs Whole House Filtration | Clear Water Concepts (2024)

FAQs

Water Softener vs Whole House Filtration | Clear Water Concepts? ›

A whole-house filtration system removes pollutants and contaminants from water. If you have a water softener but no filtration system, you'll have removed the minerals from your water, but you still may be drinking, cooking and bathing in contaminants and chemicals like: Bacteria. Heavy metals.

What is better, water filtration or water softener? ›

A water filter will remove contaminants that a softener cannot, including chemicals, bacteria, viruses, and cysts that can pose a risk to your health.

What are the disadvantages of a whole house water filter? ›

Disadvantages of Whole-House Water Filter Systems
  • It has a high initial cost. Whole-house systems are usually significantly more costly than their POU counterparts.
  • It may require professional installation. ...
  • It may reduce water pressure.

What goes first, a water filter or a water softener? ›

For city water, the filtration system should be installed before the water softener. This is because city water typically has chlorine (a disinfectant) in it and that can wear on certain parts of a softener (specifically the resin) so we want the water to go through the filtration system first.

What is the best system to remove hard water? ›

Why reverse osmosis is best for dealing with hard water
  1. Mineral removal. RO systems use a semipermeable membrane to remove not only hard water minerals but also a wide range of impurities, such as bacteria, viruses and heavy metals.
  2. Taste and purity. ...
  3. Cost-effective and eco-friendly. ...
  4. Convenience. ...
  5. Peace of mind.
Oct 19, 2023

What is the downside of a water softener? ›

Cons of Installing a Water Softener

Subjectively, soft water doesn't taste as good as hard water and doesn't provide the calcium ions that some need in their drinking water for stronger teeth and bones. A water softener is not a substitute for a home filtration system as it doesn't remove lead or other heavy metals.

Do you need a water softener if you have a whole house filtration system? ›

For the best quality water, a combination of water softening and whole-house filtration is the ideal solution. The minerals from hard water can decrease the effectiveness of whole-house filtration and decrease the quality of the water — and your lifestyle and pipes.

Is a whole house water filtration system worth it? ›

If you need chlorine-free water 24/7 for your bathing and washing, a whole house water filter will be worth the investment. But if you just need your shower water to get filtered, a shower filter will also be good enough.

What is the healthiest type of filter water? ›

Reverse Osmosis (RO)

Talk about a good bang for your buck – reverse osmosis filters are incredibly popular for a very good reason. Reverse osmosis filters are top of the line for removing a large percentage of contaminants from the water, potentially including dangerous bacteria associated with waterborne diseases.

Does a whole house water filtration system increase home value? ›

Increase Your Home's Value: Installing a whole house filter can increase your home's value, as they are considered appliances that make a home more efficient and eco-conscious. Whole house filters are investments that pay off now and in the future when it's time to sell your home.

How do I know if I need a water softener or filter? ›

While water softeners target issues like spots on dishes and buildup on appliances, water filters aim to supply better-tasting, cleaner water by removing a wider array of contaminants. These can include: Metals such as arsenic, lead, copper, iron, cadmium and hexavalent chromium.

Should I run reverse osmosis before or after water softener? ›

If your area has hard water we recommend running your water through a water softener before it enters the RO System. A water softener helps extend the life of the RO System.

Do I need a sediment filter if I have a water softener? ›

The constant exposure to large particulates and sediments wears out the system faster. Ultimately, this could lead to costly repairs or even premature replacements. Moreover, without a pre-filter, the water quality might not be optimal. Residual sediments can make the softened water cloudy and less clean.

What is the cheapest way to remove hard water? ›

Soak a cloth with warm vinegar. Then, place the cloth over your faucet to let it dissolve calcium buildup. You can also fill a Ziploc bag and fasten it over the faucet for the same effect. Fill a bucket or large bowl with warm vinegar, and place kitchen items that are spotted with calcium into it.

How do you permanently remove hardness from water? ›

Permanent hardness of water is due to dissolved salts of chlorides and sulphates of calcium and magnesium which can be removed by adding sodium carbonate (Na2CO3) (washing soda or soda ash) which reacts with these dissolved salts to form insoluble carbonates that can be removed by filtration and then water becomes soft ...

Does hard or soft water clean better? ›

Soft water is preferred for cleaning, as it doesn't tend to cause soap scum or mineral stains.

Can a water filter replace a water softener? ›

Water filters and water softeners are not the same thing. Water filters purify water by removing contaminates. Water softeners remove calcium and magnesium from the water. A water filter is good for your family's health whereas a water softener is good for your home and its appliances.

Do I need a water filter if my water is soft? ›

Soft water may still need to be filtered, whereas filtered water could still be hard water. Depending on your needs, you may only need a water filter or water softener — or in some cases, a combined water filter and softener. Soft water, no scale on plumbing fixtures, dishes etc. Does not remove any contaminants.

Is it better to have a water softener or not? ›

Advantages of home water softening

Prevents build-up of minerals (scale) on the inside of pipes, fixtures, and hot water heaters. Lengthens the life of some appliances. Reduces or prevents mineral spots on glassware. Prevents or reduces soap films and detergent curds in sinks, bathtubs, and washing machines.

Are water softeners good or bad for your health? ›

For most healthy people, the amount of added sodium in the softened water poses no health problems. However, for people who are hypertensive (have high blood pressure) and must live on a low-sodium diet or a sodium-restricted diet, the sodium in the softened water can be hazardous to people's health.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Gov. Deandrea McKenzie

Last Updated:

Views: 5724

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (66 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Gov. Deandrea McKenzie

Birthday: 2001-01-17

Address: Suite 769 2454 Marsha Coves, Debbieton, MS 95002

Phone: +813077629322

Job: Real-Estate Executive

Hobby: Archery, Metal detecting, Kitesurfing, Genealogy, Kitesurfing, Calligraphy, Roller skating

Introduction: My name is Gov. Deandrea McKenzie, I am a spotless, clean, glamorous, sparkling, adventurous, nice, brainy person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.